November 12, 2026

Chapter 2: Trust – Gus and Tamara

Colorado Gives Day 2026 - Chapter 2: Trust, Gus's story

Lauren Boykin

Gus and Tamara

Trust can’t be rushed. For a frightened cat, it’s built in small moments: a slow blink, a gentle voice, a hand that comes close and then moves away again.

This is the story of Gus, a shy longhaired boy who wasn’t sure people could be safe, and a volunteer named Tamara, who showed him one small moment at a time, that they could.

A Frightened Arrival

Our friends at Humane Society of Boulder Valley reached out to us in April about a two year old cat who was very fearful and needed behavior support. New places, sudden movements, and especially human hands sent Gus into hiding. He spent his first weeks at CCS tucked into a hidey bed, tense and watchful.

Tamara, a behavior volunteer who specializes in working with frightened cats, visited Gus every week. At first, she simply sat with him, talking softly and offering slow blinks. He sniffed the churu she brought. Most cats can’t resist the tasty treat, but Gus wouldn’t touch it.

One Lick at a Time

Then one week, a friendly cat named Creamsicle was keeping Gus company. With a buddy by his side, Tamara noticed his demeanor change. Gus shared a whole churu and let Tamara pet his head.

Progress wasn’t a straight line. After a few moves to new rooms, Gus slid backward and started hissing when people came near. We often see this kind of regression in behavior cats. The uncertainty of a new space, new sounds, and new smells requires time to adjust. Tamara kept coming back.

Gus sits on a rug, looking at the camera

In late March, she started playing a simple game. She put a dab of churu on her finger, let Gus lick it off, took her hand away, and repeated it, sometimes 15 or 20 times a session. Each time, a hand came close, something good happened, and the hand left. Gradually, she held her finger farther away, so Gus had to lean forward to reach it.

One afternoon, after about 20 minutes of churu dabs, Gus relaxed enough to start grooming, and then he stepped forward for the next dab. The next week, he turned to face the front of his bed, stretched his neck out to meet her, and closed his eyes while she scratched his head.

Protecting Every Bit of Trust

Our care team built a plan around Gus. They tried quieter spaces and pairing him with social cats, and started anti-anxiety medication to help him feel safer.

Giving it was the hard part. A negative experience with a person risked undoing weeks of progress. So the team decided to limit handling of Gus unless it was truly necessary. They weighed him while he stayed snug in his bed, then weighed the empty bed afterward and did the math.

For his medication, they played the churu game, tucking his pill into a dab of churu. Gus licked it right up. Trust he had built with one person was now helping everyone care for him.

Learning to Live in a Home

In May, Gus moved into a foster home to learn about life in a real house. The change set him back again. Weeks went by with small steps, but as his foster put it, “Slow progress is still something!” In June, Gus began eating churu off their fingers. By August, he was lounging around the house and accepting pets in his cat tower.

Later that month, Gus went home with an adopter who knew his story and was ready to go at his pace. The cat who once couldn’t be touched had learned, one dab at a time, that people could be trusted. His next chapter is just beginning.

Longhaired cat, Gus, lays upside down under a piece of furniture

Help Write the Next Chapter

Gus’s progress didn’t happen by accident. It took a volunteer who kept showing up, a care team that protected every bit of trust he built, and a foster family who patiently helped him adapt to life in a home. For 45 years, Cat Care Society has been the place for cats who need that kind of patience and care. As a 100% donor-funded shelter, we can only do this work because of supporters like you.

Every cat has a story. You help write the next chapter. Please give to Cat Care Society this Colorado Gives Day to support more cats like Gus.

Open Hours

Thurs-Mon: 12pm–6pm
Tues–Weds: Closed
Note: Email is the quickest way to reach us. We experience high call volumes, so please leave a message and we’ll get back to you.

Sign up for our Mewsletter!

Shop Our Wishlists

Please include your full name on a gift note when sending donations through Amazon or Chewy, so we can properly acknowledge your generous contribution! Without it, we won’t be able to identify that the items are from you. Also, please keep your shopping receipt, as it serves as your official donation receipt.

Help us unlock a $20,000 matching gift!

Thanks to an anonymous friend of the cats, every donation will be matched until November 22.

Deadline: November 22 16%

Clear the Shelters: Kitty Retirement Party

Saturday, August 29, 12-6 PM

Help us clear the shelter and find loving homes for all of our amazing animals!

  • Waived adoption fees for all adult cats (age 1+)
  • Foster cats onsite to visit! 
  • “Never Too Old to Be Loved” merch
  • Waived adoption fees for all adult cats (age 1+)
  • Foster cats onsite to visit!

Today is National Nonprofit Day!

Cat Care Society is celebrating 45 years of compassionate care for shelter cats. Help us continue that work by donating today!

Together, we can continue caring for cats and supporting families in need.

Kitten Season is Here

And it’s not as cute as you think! Kittens require intensive care and are highly vulnerable to illness, placing major strain on shelter resources.

This summer we will provide lifesaving care for 350+ kittens. Kitten season doesn’t slow down. With your help, neither will we.

For 45 years, Cat Care Society has said yes to the cats who need us most.

This is a story about loyalty: a senior cat who chose his person, and a person who stood by him through the hardest chapter of his life.

The 2025 Tails of the Painted Cats Auction is Open!

Place your bids in our silent auction featuring cat-themed sculptures, paintings, pottery, and more!

Bidding will close Saturday, October 18, at approximately 7:30 PM.

Shelter Hours Thursday 3-6 PM

The shelter will have a delayed opening Thursday due to shelter maintenance. Thank you for your understanding.

Get the Mewsletter

Upcoming events, special announcements, and cute cat photos delivered to your inbox bi-weekly!